ILIAClean Line Gel Liner with Built-In Sharpener | Blendable, Highly Pigmented, Water-Resistant, Budge-Resistant | Non-Toxic, Vegan, Cruelty-Free (Dusk | Brown, 0.01 oz | 0.4 g)

I recently learned that I am allergic to shellac and almost all eye liners and shadows and mascaras contain shellac. This brand, Ilia, does not contain shellac, a great find for me! I've used it for a few weeks now and it does not cause swelling or hives. Yay! As for the product itself, it goes on smoothly and evenly, stays on all day, and washes off with water. If I draw a thick line, I notice that sometimes the color transfers to the skin of the upper eye. I think that's happening because of the moist eye cream I have to put on my very sensitive eyelids. I bought the brown color and it's a really lovely shade of brown. I hope they make more colors in the future. I'm a big fan of Ilia products because they're well made and safe.

Definitely not a smoother application, but that’s ok with me because smooth application=smearing/smudging at some point in the day.This wore beautifully all day and no smudging at all!

I first tried this at my friends house , when I borrowed it to do my makeup and ever since I fell in love with it, and it’s just my go to brow pencil, I use it for my lips too as lip liner

Love clean makeup but it's not always created the same. This is a great product. Feels good, no smell, goes on easy. The only reason for the 4 stars is it doesn't seem to stay put throughout the day. I don't usually use setting spray for my average everyday so perhaps with that it would stay put and last throughout the day.

Easy to use and looks good

Perfect for tight lining

I have skin allergies so I'm very limited in what makeup I can wear. This eyeliner is on my list of 'can wear' products, so I gave it a try. In fact, I gave it a try three different times! First of all, it flakes... everywhere. It's hard to apply and so you have to go over and over your lash line and then you end up with a bunch of flakes under your eyes. The tip is too fat to give you a sleek line, so I tried to use a cotton swap the remove some of it and it smeared. It's just awful, and I waited too long to return it, so I'm stuck putting it in the donation box with all the other makeup "fails."

It’s easy to apply but it smudges and comes off too easily. Won’t buy again.