Faces Beautiful Gel Eyeliner Pencil: Precise Water Resistant, Smudge Resistant Eye Makeup Liner - Black Noir

Applying this pencil eyeliner is easy and smooth. I applied this on my lash line and water line and it has not been more than 4 hours and it has already starts to smudge on my lower lash line. When I gently swipe my tears from my lashes, it comes off. This product if not waterproof nor smudge proof. The only thing i like about this product is how smooth the application is.

Not any better or worse than anything else I’ve bought. Still smudges a little, but not bad. Probably won’t re-purchase just because there are other brands that are cheaper for same quality.

I love this eyeliner! It glides on so smooth n easy to clean up with a Q-Tip without smearing it all over your face! Sharpening it is a bit difficult but a small task for how great the eyeliner goes on whether it be a fine line or bold! It’s my new fave!

I did not like this product at all. It does run all over your eye and it’s hard to sharpen. I ya e it two stars because I at least got it shipped pretty fast. Just not a good product.

The box it came in was very suspect. One panel claimed it was a “Gel Eye Liner,” while the panel listing ingredients claimed it was a “Brunette Precision Brow Pencil.” Tested it on wrist since I’m unsure now if it’s safe for use on eyelids, and face oil lifted about 85% of the pigment after a gentle fingertip swipe.

It's a little harder than I thought it would be to apply to the waterline and doesn't last all day like I'd hoped.

Surprisingly good product. I generally use liquid eyeliners but I thought I would give this a try. Easy to apply, no tugging and it lasts all day.

They are a "no-name" brand but somehow I really like they way the liner went on and feel glad I invested in this pencil liner.